Review deepresearch.md against acceptance criteria and facts — failed
What was built
I want you to deep research recursively on how to make the most aggressive deep research system ever made. It must be fast, economical, not stop until it did find literally all information about a subject. Content type to search for must be agnostic. Only allowed search api is from https://rsearch.app.molodetz.nl/about (see docs there).. it must be native python,concurrency etcetra, no limits. when you have recursively checked if it is mathematically proven also the most aggressive deep research system, the file deepresearch.md must be written. Recursively verified to be the best (4 times). If tis all checks out you can create pull request.
Acceptance criteria
The ticket objective is satisfied: Most efficient deep research system ever made
Phases
Survey the research engine implementation and test conventions — done
Outcome: done
Commits
Commit
Summary
Node
84ac3029fce8
feat(tanya): Report per-criterion verdicts for engine acceptance criteria
3bb5cbfb04ca
dab3bb2437d1
feat(nadia): @nadia: Fix the two review findings in the research engine: (1) retry failed wor
e6071c7595ab
472a59e122db
feat(tanya): Audit tests/ for skipped, disabled, or weakened tests
46ed07b23952
808d6b4f83d5
test(sveta): Write unit and pipeline tests for the research engine
6aefb4137b95
32a17e3f5c3a
feat(tanya): Execute four recursive verification rounds and compile final report
0cee401df291
14a60ef77fde
feat(tanya): Execute engine acceptance criteria and record per-criterion verdicts
f7f10c648a7d
bc11dc18b281
test(sveta): Write live integration test against the rsearch API
101f25665b93
3ff5fc686a13
test(sveta): Write unit tests for frontier scheduling and concurrency safety
4159e2d87c90
c0a59b41381d
feat(nadia): Build content-type agnostic pipeline with bounded asyncio worker pool
e85a60edbf7b
797721701308
test(sveta): Write unit tests for deduplication and closure decision
1a3d7873cf5b
be31a2774fcc
test(sveta): Write unit tests for rsearch response parsing and error-in-body handling
05afdbb5c532
31f2c6451fb6
feat(nadia): Implement query-variant frontier and URL/content deduplication
## Unfinished
This pull request is incomplete.
- Create the pull request to main — failed
- Review deepresearch.md against acceptance criteria and facts — failed
## What was built
I want you to deep research recursively on how to make the most aggressive deep research system ever made. It must be fast, economical, not stop until it did find literally all information about a subject. Content type to search for must be agnostic. Only allowed search api is from https://rsearch.app.molodetz.nl/about (see docs there).. it must be native python,concurrency etcetra, no limits. when you have recursively checked if it is mathematically proven also the most aggressive deep research system, the file deepresearch.md must be written. Recursively verified to be the best (4 times). If tis all checks out you can create pull request.
## Acceptance criteria
- The ticket objective is satisfied: Most efficient deep research system ever made
## Phases
- **Survey the research engine implementation and test conventions** — done
Outcome: done
## Commits
| Commit | Summary | Node |
|---|---|---|
| `84ac3029fce8` | feat(tanya): Report per-criterion verdicts for engine acceptance criteria | `3bb5cbfb04ca` |
| `dab3bb2437d1` | feat(nadia): @nadia: Fix the two review findings in the research engine: (1) retry failed wor | `e6071c7595ab` |
| `472a59e122db` | feat(tanya): Audit tests/ for skipped, disabled, or weakened tests | `46ed07b23952` |
| `808d6b4f83d5` | test(sveta): Write unit and pipeline tests for the research engine | `6aefb4137b95` |
| `32a17e3f5c3a` | feat(tanya): Execute four recursive verification rounds and compile final report | `0cee401df291` |
| `14a60ef77fde` | feat(tanya): Execute engine acceptance criteria and record per-criterion verdicts | `f7f10c648a7d` |
| `bc11dc18b281` | test(sveta): Write live integration test against the rsearch API | `101f25665b93` |
| `3ff5fc686a13` | test(sveta): Write unit tests for frontier scheduling and concurrency safety | `4159e2d87c90` |
| `c0a59b41381d` | feat(nadia): Build content-type agnostic pipeline with bounded asyncio worker pool | `e85a60edbf7b` |
| `797721701308` | test(sveta): Write unit tests for deduplication and closure decision | `1a3d7873cf5b` |
| `be31a2774fcc` | test(sveta): Write unit tests for rsearch response parsing and error-in-body handling | `05afdbb5c532` |
| `31f2c6451fb6` | feat(nadia): Implement query-variant frontier and URL/content deduplication | `5e16725c0f94` |
| `e00a2db81bbc` | feat(nadia): Build research package foundation: config, rsearch-only HTTP client, TTL caches | `08bc7408f3ce` |
## Run
Cost: 0.7158 USD · Nodes: 43 · Verification: make verify
Closes #31
Outcome: done
Changed: tests/test_research_client.py:1-700
Verified by: make verify -> exit_code 0, 140 tests OK (36 new), "verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning from tests/test_api.py:1, none introduced
Findings: 36 stdlib-unittest tests with retoor header; parsing covered for web results, ai memory/provider variants, deep block (sources, grades, rounds, queries_tried), images extra metadata, chat usage, describe get/upload/raw; error-in-body asserted via real _request (patched urllib.request.urlopen): {success:false,error:"Empty query"}->RsearchError 400, providers-exhausted 503, success:false with HTTP 200, detail/title fallback, empty/invalid/non-dict body, URLError; count clamping contract asserted at client boundary: count=0 sent and parsed server clamp 1, count=25 -> 10, invalid -> 10, count=None omits param; request construction asserted (params, deep timeout 180 vs 30, cache=false, content cache fill); each parsing test asserts exact mapped values so any field-mapping regression fails; no test skipped or weakened
Open: none
Confidence: high - all acceptance criteria asserted by passing tests against verified pre-change baseline
Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d
Typosaurus-Node: 05afdbb5c5324f2ca0b0dfd8ce320f12
Typosaurus-Agent: @sveta
Refs: #31
Outcome: done
Changed: tests/test_research_dedup.py:1-303
Verified by: make verify -> exit_code 0, 176 tests OK (36 new), "verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning from tests/test_api.py, none introduced
Findings: 36 stdlib-unittest tests with retoor header; AC1 URL dedup: re-add rejected, normalized variants (case, IDNA, default port, slash collapse, trailing slash) collapse to one seen entry, duplicates across responses recorded once, whitespace-only URL normalizes to "" and is registered once then rejected; AC2 content dedup: identical and whitespace-near-identical content under different URLs rejected (content_seen=1, content_duplicates_skipped=1), blank rejected; AC3 query dedup: casefold+whitespace-collapse key, title/description/extra variants deduped, length window MIN/MAX enforced, duplicate never issued twice; AC4 closure: round with 0 new URLs and 0 new queries halts, new URL or new query continues, empty-result round halts and exhausts pending; closure decision expressed via snapshot deltas (urls_seen, queries_enqueued) because no closure module exists yet; no test skipped or weakened
Open: none
Confidence: high - every acceptance criterion asserted by passing tests; two initial failures were corrected test expectations, not implementation defects
Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d
Typosaurus-Node: 1a3d7873cf5b47eb84042647a511f3f4
Typosaurus-Agent: @sveta
Refs: #31
Outcome: done
Changed: tests/test_research_integration.py:1-70
Verified by: make verify -> exit_code 0, 199 tests OK (1 new integration test), "verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning from fastapi/testclient.py, none introduced; standalone run of tests.test_research_integration -> 1 test OK in 0.386s
Findings:
- Live smoke before writing: GET https://rsearch.app.molodetz.nl/search?query=python+asyncio&count=2&content=true -> 200, success=true, 2 results, first https://docs.python.org/3/library/asyncio.html with 2153-char content, ~1.5s
- TestLiveResearchProbe invokes ResearchPipeline.run() on one bounded web WorkItem ("python asyncio") with cache=true, default_count=2, max_concurrency=2, request_timeout 30s, wrapped in asyncio.wait_for(60s) so a hung run fails rather than blocking the suite; no skip decorator
- First run asserts requests_succeeded>=1, urls_found>=1, contents_seen>=1, and zero client-cache hits; second run on the same RsearchClient asserts cache_hit=True (pipeline.py:151 _probe_cache -> client.py:60 search_cached) and exactly zero additional network requests, proving the cache=true path end-to-end
- Only-rsearch enforcement: config.base_url asserted == https://rsearch.app.molodetz.nl (config.py:12) and every urllib.request.urlopen full_url recorded by a wrapper asserted startswith that base, plus at least one /search contact
- Non-empty result derived from live responses asserted via frontier.snapshot() urls_seen>=1 and content_seen
Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d
Typosaurus-Node: 101f25665b934f2fb52b11cbe0a4c7e8
Typosaurus-Agent: @sveta
Refs: #31
Outcome: done
Changed: none
Verified by: PYTHONPATH=src python3 -m unittest discover -s tests -q -> "Ran 226 tests in 0.634s OK", EXIT_CODE=0
Findings: Criterion 1 PASS - grep for unittest.skip|skipIf|skipUnless|SkipTest|expectedFailure|pytest.mark.skip|pytest.skip|xfail|@skip|@disabled|pytestmark across tests/ returned 0 hits; case-insensitive skipif|skipunless|onlyif|not implemented also 0; runtime report shows no skipped/expected-failure suffix
Findings: Criterion 2 PASS - grep '^\s*(pass|\.\.\.)\s*$' returned 0 hits; AST scan of all 226 test_* functions found none with only-pass body and every one contains >=1 assertion (bare assert or self.assert*/fail* call)
Findings: Criterion 3 PASS - all 25 broad 'skip' grep hits individually inspected and are duplicates_skipped/cache counters or test names, not directives: tests/test_research_engine.py:132-136, tests/test_research_dedup.py:105-233, tests/test_research_scheduling.py:226-496, tests/test_research_client.py:426,434; bare 'return' at tests/test_research_scheduling.py:149,175,289 are worker loop-exit control flow (assertions at 157-162,183-186,298-300); tests/test_research_pipeline.py:333 tests exception handling with assertions at 344-351
Findings: Criterion 4 PASS - evidence recorded as file:line references above and stored in tree finding
Findings: Supplemental sweep for __test__|no cover|pragma|.skip(|mark. returned 0 hits; suite has grown to 226 tests (previous run 219) with no skipped/expected failures reported
Open
Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d
Typosaurus-Node: 46ed07b2395240b297e0fedbe3b672cd
Typosaurus-Agent: @tanya
Refs: #31
Outcome: done
Changed: src/typosaurus_sandbox/research/engine.py:108-111,156-163,173-177, src/typosaurus_sandbox/research/pipeline.py:20-23,187-234,296-312, tests/test_research_engine.py:186-290, tests/test_research_pipeline.py:292-354
Verified by: verify() -> "make verify" exit_code 0, "Ran 226 tests OK verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning from fastapi/testclient.py import in tests/test_api.py, none introduced
Findings: Retry: pipeline.py:192-211 retries RsearchError status>=500 with backoff min(0.5*2^(attempt-1),8.0) up to RETRY_MAX_ATTEMPTS=3 (pipeline.py:20-23); status<500 or None not retried. Unexpected exceptions recorded as failure WorkOutcome in consume (pipeline.py:296-312), appended to outcomes. Closure gated on requests_failed==0 (engine.py:159-163); report.closed=requests_failed==0 (engine.py:177); failed round prevents closure, later clean round keeps report.closed False (tests/test_research_engine.py:229-290). Deep/ai wired: every popped query yields WorkItem("web",query,deep=True,ai=True) (engine.py:111); pipeline passes deep/ai to client.search and cache probe (pipeline.py:157-158,170-176); test proves seed+subtopic web calls all carry deep=True and ai=True (tests/test_research_engine.py:203-222). Fix committed as 472a59e; this node's working-tree delta is only trailing-blank cleanup; no new dependencies, client.py/cache.py/config.py/frontier.py untouched.
Open: none
Confidence: high - all six acceptance criteria met with direct
Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d
Typosaurus-Node: e6071c7595ab487b84f99476243abe28
Typosaurus-Agent: @nadia
Refs: #31
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
Unfinished
This pull request is incomplete.
What was built
I want you to deep research recursively on how to make the most aggressive deep research system ever made. It must be fast, economical, not stop until it did find literally all information about a subject. Content type to search for must be agnostic. Only allowed search api is from https://rsearch.app.molodetz.nl/about (see docs there).. it must be native python,concurrency etcetra, no limits. when you have recursively checked if it is mathematically proven also the most aggressive deep research system, the file deepresearch.md must be written. Recursively verified to be the best (4 times). If tis all checks out you can create pull request.
Acceptance criteria
Phases
Outcome: done
Commits
84ac3029fce83bb5cbfb04cadab3bb2437d1e6071c7595ab472a59e122db46ed07b23952808d6b4f83d56aefb4137b9532a17e3f5c3a0cee401df29114a60ef77fdef7f10c648a7dbc11dc18b281101f25665b933ff5fc686a134159e2d87c90c0a59b41381de85a60edbf7b7977217013081a3d7873cf5bbe31a2774fcc05afdbb5c53231f2c6451fb65e16725c0f94e00a2db81bbc08bc7408f3ceRun
Cost: 0.7158 USD · Nodes: 43 · Verification: make verify
Closes #31
Outcome: done Changed: tests/test_research_client.py:1-700 Verified by: make verify -> exit_code 0, 140 tests OK (36 new), "verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning from tests/test_api.py:1, none introduced Findings: 36 stdlib-unittest tests with retoor header; parsing covered for web results, ai memory/provider variants, deep block (sources, grades, rounds, queries_tried), images extra metadata, chat usage, describe get/upload/raw; error-in-body asserted via real _request (patched urllib.request.urlopen): {success:false,error:"Empty query"}->RsearchError 400, providers-exhausted 503, success:false with HTTP 200, detail/title fallback, empty/invalid/non-dict body, URLError; count clamping contract asserted at client boundary: count=0 sent and parsed server clamp 1, count=25 -> 10, invalid -> 10, count=None omits param; request construction asserted (params, deep timeout 180 vs 30, cache=false, content cache fill); each parsing test asserts exact mapped values so any field-mapping regression fails; no test skipped or weakened Open: none Confidence: high - all acceptance criteria asserted by passing tests against verified pre-change baseline Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d Typosaurus-Node: 05afdbb5c5324f2ca0b0dfd8ce320f12 Typosaurus-Agent: @sveta Refs: #31Outcome: done Changed: src/typosaurus_sandbox/research/engine.py:108-111,156-163,173-177, src/typosaurus_sandbox/research/pipeline.py:20-23,187-234,296-312, tests/test_research_engine.py:186-290, tests/test_research_pipeline.py:292-354 Verified by: verify() -> "make verify" exit_code 0, "Ran 226 tests OK verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning from fastapi/testclient.py import in tests/test_api.py, none introduced Findings: Retry: pipeline.py:192-211 retries RsearchError status>=500 with backoff min(0.5*2^(attempt-1),8.0) up to RETRY_MAX_ATTEMPTS=3 (pipeline.py:20-23); status<500 or None not retried. Unexpected exceptions recorded as failure WorkOutcome in consume (pipeline.py:296-312), appended to outcomes. Closure gated on requests_failed==0 (engine.py:159-163); report.closed=requests_failed==0 (engine.py:177); failed round prevents closure, later clean round keeps report.closed False (tests/test_research_engine.py:229-290). Deep/ai wired: every popped query yields WorkItem("web",query,deep=True,ai=True) (engine.py:111); pipeline passes deep/ai to client.search and cache probe (pipeline.py:157-158,170-176); test proves seed+subtopic web calls all carry deep=True and ai=True (tests/test_research_engine.py:203-222). Fix committed as 472a59e; this node's working-tree delta is only trailing-blank cleanup; no new dependencies, client.py/cache.py/config.py/frontier.py untouched. Open: none Confidence: high - all six acceptance criteria met with direct Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d Typosaurus-Node: e6071c7595ab487b84f99476243abe28 Typosaurus-Agent: @nadia Refs: #31Outcome: done Changed: none Verified by: make verify -> EXIT_CODE=0, "Ran 226 tests in 0.959s OK verification passed"; only pre-existing StarletteDeprecationWarning Findings: - C1 PASS - grep: 0 non-rsearch URL literals; test_research_client.py:695 asserts rsearch URL; test_research_integration.py:94-96 asserts all URLs start RSEARCH_BASE_URL - C2 PASS - test_research_scheduling.py:131-163 max_concurrency==8, peak==8, 64 drained, pending 0; :459/:499 pool bound - C3 PASS - test_research_pipeline.py:272-289 endpoints web/images->/search describe->/describe chat->/chat; test_research_engine.py:141-146 content_types web:3 images:3 chat:3 describe:1 - C4 PASS - test_research_dedup.py:107,149,161,186,213 URL/content/query dedup; test_research_scheduling.py:235,248,266 concurrency dedup - C5 PASS - test_research_engine.py:79-101 closed round1 (new_urls=0,new_queries=0); :103-147 discovery then closure; test_research_dedup.py:236-291 closure matrix - C6 PASS - AST 9 modules: 0 annotation problems; 21 logger.info + 10 logger.debug; retoor header 9/9 - C7 PASS - grep TODO|FIXME|placeholder|stub: 0 hits - C8 PASS - make verify EXIT_CODE=0, 226 tests OK, verification passed; no new warning - Adversarial - run(" \n\t") and run("") -> ValueError "research subject must not be empty", no API call, no hang Open: none Confidence: high - all 8 engine criteria executed first-hand with asserting tests and verify output Typosaurus-Run: 4e2afb673c7f4578a12276d9181b982d Typosaurus-Node: 3bb5cbfb04ca4194a0b509da6f861dbc Typosaurus-Agent: @tanya Refs: #31View command line instructions
Checkout
From your project repository, check out a new branch and test the changes.