Review first part.

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
retoor 2024-12-23 17:55:04 +01:00
parent 114bc4bf07
commit 79026fd96c
31 changed files with 341 additions and 0 deletions
Show Stats Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

11
.reviews/Package.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "// swift-tools-version: 6.0\n// The swift-tools-version declares the minimum version of Swift required to build this package.\n\nimport PackageDescription\n\nlet package = Package(\n name: \"SwiftDevRant\",\n platforms: [.iOS(.v13), .macOS(.v10_15), .tvOS(.v13), .watchOS(.v6), .driverKit(.v19), .macCatalyst(.v13), .visionOS(.v1)],\n products: [\n // Products define the executables and libraries a package produces, making them visible to other packages.\n .library(\n name: \"SwiftDevRant\",\n targets: [\"SwiftDevRant\"]\n ),\n ],\n dependencies: [\n .package(url: \"https://github.com/WilhelmOks/KreeRequest\", .upToNextMajor(from: \"1.0.3\")),\n ],\n targets: [\n // Targets are the basic building blocks of a package, defining a module or a test suite.\n // Targets can depend on other targets in this package and products from dependencies.\n .target(\n name: \"SwiftDevRant\",\n dependencies: [\"KreeRequest\"]\n ),\n .testTarget(\n name: \"SwiftDevRantTests\",\n dependencies: [\"SwiftDevRant\"]\n ),\n ]\n)\n",
"review": "**Grade: 7**\n\n# Bugs\n- No explicit bugs were found in the code. However, compatibility with \"swift-tools-version: 6.0\" might need future validation as this version wasn't officially recognized up to October 2023.\n\n# Optimizations\n- Consider updating `swift-tools-version` to a stable and widely recognized version (e.g., 5.7) to ensure compatibility with existing Swift toolchains.\n- Adding more comments within the code to describe functionality and dependencies could enhance readability and maintainability.\n\n# Good points\n- Proper use of Swift Package Manager manifest file structure.\n- Comprehensive platform support including `iOS`, `macOS`, `tvOS`, `watchOS`, `driverKit`, `macCatalyst`, and `visionOS`.\n- The package dependency is clearly defined with a specified source and versioning.\n\n# Summary\nOverall, this `Package.swift` file adheres well to the standard Swift Package Manager format with a clear definition of products, dependencies, and targets. Compatibility considerations with tool versions could improve wider adoption and toolchain support.\n\n# Open source alternatives\n- **Alamofire**: A widely-used Swift library for HTTP networking, which may serve as an alternative to `KreeRequest` if HTTP functionalities are being utilized.\n- **Moya**: A Swift network abstraction layer that can be considered for handling networking tasks.",
"filename": "Package.swift",
"path": "Package.swift",
"directory": "",
"grade": 7,
"size": 1130,
"line_count": 32
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Conversion/ImageDataConversion.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "#if os(iOS)\nimport UIKit\n#elseif os(macOS)\nimport AppKit\n#endif\n\nprivate struct ImageHeaderData {\n static let png: UInt8 = 0x89\n static let jpeg: UInt8 = 0xFF\n static let gif: UInt8 = 0x47\n static let tiff_01: UInt8 = 0x49\n static let tiff_02: UInt8 = 0x4D\n}\n\nenum ImageFormat {\n case png\n case jpeg\n case gif\n case tiff\n}\n\nextension Data {\n var imageFormat: ImageFormat? {\n let buffer = self.first\n if buffer == ImageHeaderData.png {\n return .png\n } else if buffer == ImageHeaderData.jpeg {\n return .jpeg\n } else if buffer == ImageHeaderData.gif {\n return .gif\n } else if buffer == ImageHeaderData.tiff_01 || buffer == ImageHeaderData.tiff_02 {\n return .tiff\n } else {\n return nil\n }\n }\n}\n\npublic protocol ImageDataConverter {\n /// Converts the image `data` to another format and returns the resulting Data.\n func convert(_ data: Data) -> Data\n}\n\npublic extension ImageDataConverter {\n #if os(macOS)\n func jpegData(from image: NSImage) -> Data? {\n guard let cgImage = image.cgImage(forProposedRect: nil, context: nil, hints: nil) else { return nil }\n let bitmapRep = NSBitmapImageRep(cgImage: cgImage)\n return bitmapRep.representation(using: .jpeg, properties: [:])\n }\n #endif\n}\n\nextension Collection where Element == ImageDataConverter {\n /// Applies all converters to the provided `data` sequentially and returns the result.\n func convert(_ data: Data) -> Data {\n var result = data\n for converter in self {\n result = converter.convert(result)\n }\n return result\n }\n}\n\n/// An `ImageDataConverter` that converts image formats which are not supported by devRant to jpeg.\n/// Data of supported formats is just returned without any conversion.\n/// If the conversion fails, the original Data is returned.\npublic struct UnsupportedToJpegImageDataConverter: ImageDataConverter {\n public func convert(_ data: Data) -> Data {\n switch data.imageFormat {\n case nil: // Format not recognized so it's probably not supported by devRant.\n #if os(iOS)\n return UIImage(data: data)?.jpegData(compressionQuality: 1) ?? data\n #elseif os(macOS)\n return NSImage(data: data).flatMap(jpegData) ?? data\n #else\n return data // This converter doesn't support platforms other than iOS and macOS. If you need to support other platforms, you can implement and use an own converter.\n #endif\n default: // Supported format recognized. No conversion needed.\n return data\n }\n }\n}\n\npublic extension ImageDataConverter where Self == UnsupportedToJpegImageDataConverter {\n static var unsupportedToJpeg: Self { Self() }\n}\n",
"review": "# 8\n\n## Bugs\n- No apparent bugs are evident within the given code; it seems to perform as intended.\n\n## Optimizations\n- The `convert` function in `UnsupportedToJpegImageDataConverter` makes use of platform-specific conditional compilation. This strategy might introduce code repetition. Consider abstracting platform-specific code into separate helper functions to avoid repetition.\n- Utilize guard statements in place of nested `if-else` to improve readability when determining the image format.\n- Consider using `switch` with associated values pattern, as it might make additions to image formats more straightforward.\n\n## Good points\n- The code makes good use of conditional compilation to cater to differences between iOS and macOS.\n- The implementation of the \"UnsupportedToJpegImageDataConverter\" effectively handles unsupported image formats by converting them to JPEG, which is a practical approach.\n- Use of extensions to add functionality to `Data` makes the code clean and modular.\n- Clear and descriptive documentation provided for methods and protocols.\n- Encapsulation using `private struct` for header data improves the code organization and readability.\n\n## Summary\nThe code is well-organized and provides functionality to determine image formats and convert unsupported formats to JPEG. It efficiently caters to platform-specific needs while maintaining a modular approach through the use of extensions. There is potential for optimization in terms of code readability and efficiency regarding image format determination and handling platform-specific tasks.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- **SDWebImage**: A powerful tool for asynchronous image downloading and caching, equipped with functionalities for image format detection and conversion.\n- **AlamofireImage**: Another option that offers image downloading and caching capabilities with additional support for handling different image formats.",
"filename": "ImageDataConversion.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Conversion/ImageDataConversion.swift",
"directory": "Conversion",
"grade": 8,
"size": 2833,
"line_count": 88
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRant/DevRantApiError.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// Represents an error coming directly from the devrant API.\npublic struct DevRantApiError: Swift.Error {\n public let message: String\n}\n\npublic extension DevRantApiError {\n struct CodingData: Decodable, Swift.Error {\n let error: String\n }\n}\n\npublic extension DevRantApiError.CodingData {\n var decoded: DevRantApiError {\n .init(message: error)\n }\n}\n",
"review": "7\n\n## Bugs\n- No immediate bugs are evident from the code provided.\n\n## Optimizations\n- Consider making `CodingData` struct also `public`, since it\u2019s declared inside a `public` struct but doesn't have default access level modifiers for its properties.\n- Include documentation comments for properties and methods to improve code readability and maintainability.\n- The `error` property in `CodingData` could be `public` if it needs to be accessed outside of the containing module.\n \n## Good points\n- Provides a clear and concise representation of an error by abstracting it into a struct.\n- Proper use of Swift\u2019s error protocol, adhering to Swift's error handling mechanisms.\n- The `decoded` computed property is a useful bridge to convert between different error representations.\n\n## Summary\nThe code is well-structured and achieves its goal of representing and decoding errors from the DevRant API effectively. However, it could benefit from a few access level adjustments and additional documentation for greater clarity and usability.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- [Alamofire](https://github.com/Alamofire/Alamofire): While primarily a networking library, it includes error handling capabilities.\n- [Moya](https://github.com/Moya/Moya): A powerful networking abstraction layer that can be used with customizable error handling features.",
"filename": "DevRantApiError.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRant/DevRantApiError.swift",
"directory": "DevRant",
"grade": 7,
"size": 378,
"line_count": 17
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRant/DevRantBackend.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import KreeRequest\n\nstruct DevRantBackend: Backend {\n let baseURL = \"https://devrant.com/api/\"\n}\n",
"review": "6\n\n### Bugs\n- The code might compile without any bugs in Swift, but the functionality is limited and it's hard to identify deeper logical errors without context or additional implementation.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Define `baseURL` as `static let` if it doesn't need to change between instances to save memory since it will be shared across all instances.\n- Implement methods for network requests to make the 'Backend' functional.\n\n### Good points\n- The code is simple and adheres to basic Swift conventions.\n- Use of a constant for `baseURL` ensures that the URL is not accidentally modified.\n\n### Summary\nThe snippet provided is a basic structure of a network backend for interacting with the DevRant API but lacks concrete implementations for the Backend protocol, such as network request methods. Due to its simplicity, there's little functionality or error handling. It serves as a good starting point but needs further detailing to be practically useful.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **Alamofire**: A well-established Swift-based library for HTTP networking.\n- **Moya**: A powerful abstraction layer on top of Alamofire, specifically designed for network requests like this.\n- **URLSession**: The native framework to handle HTTP requests, which can be utilized more extensively.",
"filename": "DevRantBackend.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRant/DevRantBackend.swift",
"directory": "DevRant",
"grade": 6,
"size": 100,
"line_count": 6
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRant/DevRantJSONCoder.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\nimport KreeRequest\n\nextension JSONEncoder {\n static let devRant: JSONEncoder = {\n let encoder = JSONEncoder()\n encoder.dateEncodingStrategy = .iso8601\n return encoder\n }()\n}\n\nextension JSONDecoder {\n static let devRant: JSONDecoder = {\n let decoder = JSONDecoder()\n decoder.dateDecodingStrategy = .iso8601WithOptionalFractionalSeconds\n return decoder\n }()\n}\n",
"review": "**8**\n\n## Bugs\n- The `JSONDecoder`'s `dateDecodingStrategy` set to `.iso8601WithOptionalFractionalSeconds` does not exist; it should be `.iso8601`. If a custom strategy for optional fractional seconds is needed, this needs to be implemented separately.\n\n## Optimizations\n- Consider adding error handling or logging to catch issues during JSON encoding/decoding.\n- If `dateDecodingStrategy` with optional fractional seconds is truly required, implement a custom decoding strategy.\n\n## Good points\n- Encapsulation of `JSONEncoder` and `JSONDecoder` configuration within static properties improves code reusability and centralizes configuration.\n- Use of the `.iso8601` date encoding/decoding strategy aligns with a standardized format for date/time.\n\n## Summary\nThis piece of code provides a well-structured approach through extensions to configure `JSONEncoder` and `JSONDecoder` with ISO8601 date strategies, which are commonly used for APIs. The method for encoding is correctly standardized, but there's an issue with using a non-existent decoding strategy for handling optional fractional seconds. The structure itself is clean, maintains good practices for code reusability, and is set up for potentially easy maintenance. Adding error handling could catch configuration issues during actual encoding/decoding operations.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- SwiftyJSON: A popular Swift library to deal with JSON data with additional features and error handling.\n- CodableAlamofire: Provides extensions for Alamofire to handle JSON encoding/decoding in a type-safe manner with Codable.",
"filename": "DevRantJSONCoder.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRant/DevRantJSONCoder.swift",
"directory": "DevRant",
"grade": 8,
"size": 430,
"line_count": 19
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/DevRantRequest.swift.md Normal file
View File

File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/AttachedImage.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// An image that the user has uploaded for his rant or comment.\npublic struct AttachedImage: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let url: String\n public let width: Int\n public let height: Int\n \n public init(url: String, width: Int, height: Int) {\n self.url = url\n self.width = width\n self.height = height\n }\n}\n\nextension AttachedImage {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let url: String\n let width: Int\n let height: Int\n }\n}\n\nextension AttachedImage.CodingData {\n var decoded: AttachedImage {\n .init(\n url: url,\n width: width,\n height: height\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "9\n\n### Bugs\n- No significant bugs found in the visible portion of the code.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Simplify the Codable conformance by making `AttachedImage` conform directly to `Codable` instead of using a nested struct for encoding/decoding.\n- Consider using `URL` type instead of `String` for the `url` property for better type safety and validation.\n\n### Good points\n- Adheres to Swift's best practices with the use of `public` access control.\n- Smart use of `Hashable` and `Sendable` protocols suggesting immutability and safety in concurrent programming contexts.\n- Clear and straightforward initialization method.\n\n### Summary\nThe `AttachedImage` struct is well-designed with a focus on thread safety and immutability, as indicated by its conformance to `Sendable` and `Hashable`. The code is clean and concise, with only minor suggestions for improvement mainly around potential simplification and improved type safety. \n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **Kingfisher**: A powerful, pure-Swift library for downloading and caching images from the web.\n- **SDWebImage**: An asynchronous image downloader with cache support as a UIImageView category.",
"filename": "AttachedImage.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/AttachedImage.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 9,
"size": 661,
"line_count": 31
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/AuthToken.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\npublic struct AuthToken: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let id: Int\n public let key: String\n public let expireTime: Date\n public let userId: Int\n \n public init(id: Int, key: String, expireTime: Date, userId: Int) {\n self.id = id\n self.key = key\n self.expireTime = expireTime\n self.userId = userId\n }\n \n public var isExpired: Bool {\n expireTime < Date()\n }\n}\n\npublic extension AuthToken {\n public struct CodingData: Codable {\n public struct Container: Codable {\n let auth_token: AuthToken.CodingData\n }\n \n public let id: Int\n public let key: String\n public let expire_time: Int\n public let user_id: Int\n }\n}\n\npublic extension AuthToken.CodingData {\n public var decoded: AuthToken {\n .init(\n id: id,\n key: key,\n expireTime: Date(timeIntervalSince1970: TimeInterval(expire_time)),\n userId: user_id\n )\n }\n}\n\npublic extension AuthToken {\n public var encoded: AuthToken.CodingData {\n .init(\n id: id,\n key: key,\n expire_time: Int(expireTime.timeIntervalSince1970),\n user_id: userId\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "## 8\n\n### Bugs\n- No explicit bugs identified within the code provided.\n\n### Optimizations\n- The `public` access modifier is unnecessary in extensions if the enclosing type is already public.\n- Consider using `DateFormatter` for handling date formats if the date string needs to be human-readable.\n- The naming convention for variable `expire_time` in the `CodingData` struct could be `camelCase` consistent with Swift's convention.\n\n### Good points\n- The use of `Codable` ensures easy conversion of data to and from JSON or other formats.\n- The code clearly defines a structure for an authentication token and encapsulates its properties well.\n- `isExpired` computed property provides a readable way to check expiration status.\n\n### Summary\nThe code provides a clear and efficient structure for handling authentication tokens. It uses Swift's features effectively, such as `Codable` for easy serialization and `extension` for organizing code. The implementation can benefit slightly from adhering to naming conventions and removing unnecessary access modifiers.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- [JWT.swift](https://github.com/IBM-Swift/Swift-JWT) - A Swift library for JSON Web Tokens.\n- [Vapor's JWT Package](https://github.com/vapor/jwt) - Provides comprehensive JWT functionalities in Swift.",
"filename": "AuthToken.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/AuthToken.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 1259,
"line_count": 55
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Collaboration.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public struct Collaboration: Hashable, Sendable {\n public enum Kind: Int, Sendable {\n case openSourceIdea = 1\n case existingOpenSourceProject = 2\n case projectIdea = 3\n case existingProject = 4\n }\n \n public let kind: Kind?\n public let kindDescription: String\n public let description: String\n public let techStack: String\n public let teamSize: String\n public let url: String\n \n public init(kind: Kind?, kindDescription: String, description: String, techStack: String, teamSize: String, url: String) {\n self.kind = kind\n self.kindDescription = kindDescription\n self.description = description\n self.techStack = techStack\n self.teamSize = teamSize\n self.url = url\n }\n}\n",
"review": "# 7\n\n### Bugs\n- None identified in the current code.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider using `URL` type instead of `String` for the `url` property to take advantage of URL validation.\n- `teamSize` could potentially be a more specific type, like `Int` if it typically represents a numerical value.\n- If future modifications may include validating the `techStack` or `teamSize`, consider providing computed properties or methods for such validations.\n\n### Good points\n- Utilizes Swift `struct` which provides value semantics, making it safer and potentially more efficient.\n- Implements `Hashable` which is necessary for using this struct in a set or as dictionary keys.\n- Supports `Sendable`, enhancing concurrency safety and assisting with Swift's concurrency model.\n- Use of `enum` for `Kind` gives better type safety and readability.\n\n### Summary\nThe `Collaboration` struct is well-implemented with key Swift protocols (`Hashable` and `Sendable`). It wisely uses an `enum` for `Kind` to enhance readability and safety. The current implementation performs adequately, but small optimizations could enhance type safety and future-proof the code for modifications. There are no apparent bugs, which denotes reliable code quality. Moreover, using more specific types for certain properties could further optimize this structure for real-world applications.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **Project Open**: A comprehensive project management and collaboration platform that may include task and resource reporting.\n- **Taiga**: An open-source project management tool for agile developers & designers.",
"filename": "Collaboration.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Collaboration.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 771,
"line_count": 25
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Comment.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\n/// A comment posted by a user inside of a rant.\npublic struct Comment: Identifiable, Hashable, Sendable {\n /// The id of this comment.\n public let id: Int\n \n /// The id of the rant that the comment belongs to.\n public let rantId: Int\n \n /// The current logged in user's vote on this comment.\n public let voteState: VoteState\n \n /// The number of upvotes from other users.\n public let score: Int\n \n /// The user who wrote this comment.\n public let author: User\n \n /// The time when this comment was created.\n public let created: Date\n \n /// True if this comment is edited by the author.\n public let isEdited: Bool\n \n /// The text contents of this comment.\n public let text: String\n \n /// The URLs and user mentions inside of the text of this comment.\n public let linksInText: [Link]\n \n /// The optional image that the user has uploaded for this comment.\n public let image: AttachedImage?\n \n public init(id: Int, rantId: Int, voteState: VoteState, score: Int, author: User, created: Date, isEdited: Bool, text: String, linksInText: [Link], image: AttachedImage?) {\n self.id = id\n self.rantId = rantId\n self.voteState = voteState\n self.score = score\n self.author = author\n self.created = created\n self.isEdited = isEdited\n self.text = text\n self.linksInText = linksInText\n self.image = image\n }\n}\n\nextension Comment {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let id: Int\n let rant_id: Int\n let body: String\n let score: Int\n let created_time: Int\n let vote_state: Int\n let links: [Link.CodingData]?\n let user_id: Int\n let user_username: String\n let user_score: Int\n let user_avatar: User.Avatar.CodingData\n let user_avatar_lg: User.Avatar.CodingData?\n let user_dpp: Int?\n let attached_image: AttachedImage.CodingData?\n let edited: Bool?\n }\n}\n\nextension Comment.CodingData {\n var decoded: Comment {\n .init(\n id: id,\n rantId: rant_id,\n voteState: .init(rawValue: vote_state) ?? .unvoted,\n score: score,\n author: .init(\n id: user_id,\n name: user_username,\n score: user_score,\n devRantSupporter: (user_dpp ?? 0) != 0,\n avatarSmall: user_avatar.decoded,\n avatarLarge: user_avatar_lg?.decoded\n ),\n created: Date(timeIntervalSince1970: TimeInterval(created_time)),\n isEdited: edited ?? false,\n text: body,\n linksInText: links?.map(\\.decoded) ?? [],\n image: attached_image?.decoded\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**7**\n\n### Bugs\n- No evident bugs in the provided code.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Use more descriptive parameter names in the `init` method of `Comment` for clarity.\n- Utilize `lazy var` for properties that are computationally expensive and are not needed immediately upon object instantiation.\n- Consider making `Comment` conform to `Codable` directly instead of adding an inner `CodingData` struct.\n\n### Good points\n- Well-structured and organized code with clear commenting, aiding readability.\n- Effective use of Swift features such as `struct`, `extension`, and computed properties.\n- Thoughtful use of encapsulation and data transformation through the `CodingData` structure.\n\n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured, leveraging Swift's language features deftly, like extensions, to maintain code clarity and manage complexity. Code comments provide a good explanation of each property\u2019s purpose, aiding future maintenance. It\u2019s ready for integration but could be optimized for clarity and performance.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **SwiftyJSON**: Although primarily focused on JSON parsing, SwiftyJSON could ease the decoding process.\n- **Codable** from the Swift Standard Library: Direct use of Codable can provide a cleaner approach without needing separate structs for coding/decoding purposes.",
"filename": "Comment.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Comment.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 2796,
"line_count": 92
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/DownvoteReason.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// Represents the reason for downvoting.\npublic enum DownvoteReason: Int, Hashable, Sendable {\n case notForMe = 0\n case repost = 1\n case offensiveOrSpam = 2\n}\n",
"review": "7\n\n### Bugs\n- No apparent bugs in the code snippet provided. The enum appears to fulfill its intended basic function.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider adding documentation comments for each case to improve code readability and maintainability.\n- The `Sendable` protocol conformance might be unnecessary unless concurrency safety is required in your application.\n\n### Good points\n- Utilizes `enum` for defining a clear and finite set of possible reasons for downvoting.\n- Conforms to `Hashable`, making it usable in collections that require hashing.\n- Integer raw values are assigned, which might be useful for storage or interoperability with other systems.\n\n### Summary\nThe code snippet defines an enumeration `DownvoteReason` with three possible values. It effectively uses Swift enum features to offer a constrained set of downvote reasons and uses integer raw values for integration or storage purposes. The code is clean and follows good practices for its context, but minor improvements, like documentation, would make it better.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- [Swift Enumerations Guide](https://docs.swift.org/swift-book/documentation/the-swift-programming-language/enumerations): This isn't an alternative product per se, but it is a comprehensive guide on how to use enums in Swift, which may be useful for expanding upon this code.",
"filename": "DownvoteReason.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/DownvoteReason.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 169,
"line_count": 7
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Link.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// A URL or a user mention link in a rant or comment.\npublic struct Link: Hashable, Sendable {\n public enum Kind: String, Sendable {\n case url = \"url\"\n case userMention = \"mention\"\n }\n \n public let kind: Kind\n \n /// The full URL.\n public let url: String\n \n /// No idea what this is and what it is supposed to be used for.\n public let shortURL: String?\n \n /// The url as it is visible in the text of the rant or comment.\n public let title: String\n \n /// The starting position of the link in the overall text of the rant or comment.\n /// - Important: The devRant API returns offsets for links in byte offsets and not in normalized character offsets. Please take this into account when using these offsets.\n public let start: Int?\n \n /// The ending position of the link in the overall text of the rant or comment.\n /// - Important: The devRant API returns offsets for links in byte offsets and not in normalized character offsets. Please take this into account when using these offsets.\n public let end: Int?\n \n public init(kind: Link.Kind, url: String, shortURL: String?, title: String, start: Int?, end: Int?) {\n self.kind = kind\n self.url = url\n self.shortURL = shortURL\n self.title = title\n self.start = start\n self.end = end\n }\n}\n\nextension Link {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let type: String\n let url: String\n let short_url: String\n let title: String\n let start: Int?\n let end: Int?\n }\n}\n\nextension Link.CodingData {\n var decoded: Link {\n .init(\n kind: .init(rawValue: type) ?? .url,\n url: url,\n shortURL: short_url,\n title: title,\n start: start,\n end: end\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "# 7\n\n## Bugs\n- No direct bugs are visible, but forced optional handling might cause runtime issues if not attended carefully.\n \n## Optimizations\n- Consider using optional binding to safely unwrap `Kind` from `CodingData` without defaulting to a URL.\n- The field `shortURL` lacks a clear purpose; consider adding documentation or removing if unnecessary.\n \n## Good points\n- The code structure is clear and follows Swift\u2019s naming conventions correctly.\n- Considering `Link` as `Hashable` and `Sendable` increases code robustness and allows threading and uniqueness checks.\n- Comments are used effectively to convey information about the properties and edge cases like byte offsets.\n\n## Summary\nThe code snippet effectively models a URL or a user mention link with Swift\u2019s `struct`, providing separate handling through the use of `Kind` enum. It properly marks important properties in consideration of specific API responses, maintaining readability. However, the default handling when decoding the `kind` property could potentially mask incorrect data inputs without alerting the developer, and optionally documented properties might be confusing.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- [Alamofire](https://github.com/Alamofire/Alamofire) for handling network requests and URL management.\n- [SwiftLinkPreview](https://github.com/LeonardoCardoso/SwiftLinkPreview) for extracting or previewing URLs, which can handle link functionalities when interacting with APIs.",
"filename": "Link.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Link.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 1834,
"line_count": 60
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Notification.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\n/// A notification about activities in a rant or a comment.\npublic struct Notification: Hashable, Identifiable, Sendable {\n public enum Kind: String, Sendable {\n /// An upvote for a rant.\n case rantUpvote = \"content_vote\"\n \n /// An upvote for a comment.\n case commentUpvote = \"comment_vote\"\n \n /// A new comment in one of the logged in user's rants.\n case newCommentInOwnRant = \"comment_content\"\n \n /// A new comment in a rant that the logged in user has commented in.\n case newComment = \"comment_discuss\"\n \n /// A mention of the logged in user in a comment.\n case mentionInComment = \"comment_mention\"\n \n /// A new rant posted by someone that the logged in user is subscribed to.\n case newRantOfSubscribedUser = \"rant_sub\"\n }\n \n /// The id of the rant associated with this notification.\n public let rantId: Int\n \n /// The id of the comment associated with this notification, if this notification is for a comment.\n public let commentId: Int?\n \n /// The time when this notification was created.\n public let created: Date\n \n /// True if the user has already read this notification.\n public let read: Bool\n \n /// The type of this notification.\n public let kind: Kind\n \n /// The id of the user who triggered the notification.\n public let userId: Int\n \n public var id: String {\n [\n String(rantId),\n commentId.flatMap{ String($0) } ?? \"-\",\n String(Int(created.timeIntervalSince1970)),\n String(read),\n kind.rawValue,\n String(userId)\n ].joined(separator: \"|\")\n }\n \n public init(rantId: Int, commentId: Int?, created: Date, read: Bool, kind: Notification.Kind, userId: Int) {\n self.rantId = rantId\n self.commentId = commentId\n self.created = created\n self.read = read\n self.kind = kind\n self.userId = userId\n }\n}\n\nextension Notification {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let rant_id: Int\n let comment_id: Int?\n let created_time: Int\n let read: Int\n let type: String\n let uid: Int\n }\n}\n\nextension Notification.CodingData {\n var decoded: Notification {\n .init(\n rantId: rant_id,\n commentId: comment_id,\n created: Date(timeIntervalSince1970: TimeInterval(created_time)),\n read: read != 0,\n kind: .init(rawValue: type) ?? .newComment,\n userId: uid\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**8**\n\n### Bugs\n- No significant bugs identified in this code snippet.\n\n### Optimizations\n- The `id` generation logic could potentially be simplified using string interpolation.\n- Consider using `enum` cases directly for type safety and clarity in decoding logic.\n- Mapping the raw `type` to `Kind` could be more exhaustive or safeguarded with a fallback or error handling if unknown values arise.\n\n### Good points\n- The structuring using nested enumerations and extensions leads to clear organization.\n- Conformance to Swift protocols like `Hashable`, `Identifiable`, `Sendable`, and `Codable` enhances usability and makes it versatile in different contexts.\n- The use of `flatMap` facilitates clean handling of optional values.\n- Utilization of descriptive comments for each aspect of the notification is helpful for understanding.\n\n### Summary\nThis code defines a `Notification` struct with complete interoperability, providing encoding and decoding functionality seamlessly. The struct is well-organized with clear enums and comments to provide context and functionality. It efficiently uses Swift's optional handling and protocol conformance to offer a robust, clear structure for representing user notifications.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **SwiftNotificationBanner**: A lightweight library to display notification bars in a customizable and quick manner.\n- **Noty**: A simple in-app notification framework inspired by iOS system notifications.\n- **MessageKit**: A community-driven replacement for JSQMessagesViewController that builds upon Apple's new UI elements for dealing with notifications.",
"filename": "Notification.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Notification.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 2614,
"line_count": 87
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed+Mapping.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\npublic extension NotificationFeed {\n public struct MappedNotificationItem: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let rantId: Rant.ID\n public let commentId: Comment.ID?\n public let userId: Int\n public let userAvatar: User.Avatar\n public let userName: String\n public let notificationKind: Notification.Kind\n public let created: Date\n public let isRead: Bool\n \n public init(rantId: Rant.ID, commentId: Comment.ID?, userId: Int, userAvatar: User.Avatar, userName: String, notificationKind: Notification.Kind, created: Date, isRead: Bool) {\n self.rantId = rantId\n self.commentId = commentId\n self.userId = userId\n self.userAvatar = userAvatar\n self.userName = userName\n self.notificationKind = notificationKind\n self.created = created\n self.isRead = isRead\n }\n }\n \n public var mappedItems: [MappedNotificationItem] {\n notifications.map { notification in\n let rantId = notification.rantId\n let commentId = notification.commentId\n let userId = notification.userId\n let userInfo = userInfos.first { $0.userId == userId }\n let userAvatar = userInfo?.avatar ?? .init(colorHex: \"cccccc\", imageUrlPath: nil)\n let userName = userInfo?.username ?? \"\"\n \n return MappedNotificationItem(\n rantId: rantId,\n commentId: commentId,\n userId: userId,\n userAvatar: userAvatar,\n userName: userName,\n notificationKind: notification.kind,\n created: notification.created,\n isRead: notification.read\n )\n }\n }\n \n public var unreadByCategory: [NotificationFeed.Category: Int] {\n [\n .all: unreadNumbers.all,\n .upvotes: unreadNumbers.upvotes,\n .mentions: unreadNumbers.mentions,\n .comments: unreadNumbers.comments,\n .subscriptions: unreadNumbers.subscriptions,\n ]\n }\n}\n",
"review": "8\n\n### Bugs\n- `public` keyword is redundant in the extension as `NotificationFeed` is already marked `public`, making its contents inherently public.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider caching `userInfos.first { $0.userId == userId }` if this operation is performed frequently, to minimize searching through the userInfos array repeatedly.\n- Consider using guard or if-let statements to handle optional values more safely and improve code readability.\n\n### Good points\n- The code makes good use of Swift's strong typing with specific types for each property.\n- Use of collections like arrays and dictionaries is appropriate and idiomatic.\n- Adopting `Hashable` and `Sendable` protocols for the `MappedNotificationItem` adds future-proofing, considering Swift concurrency.\n\n### Summary\nThe provided Swift code is clean and follows Swift's best practices in handling data mapping and optional unwrapping fairly well. The encapsulation through extensions and struct initializers is well handled. However, some redundant `public` access specifiers could be removed for conciseness, and a bit more optimization in handling optional values could improve readability and efficiency.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- [Rocket.Chat](https://github.com/RocketChat/Rocket.Chat) provides a framework for managing notifications.\n- [OneSignal](https://github.com/OneSignal/OneSignal-iOS-SDK) offers implementation options for handling notification feeds with diverse functionalities.",
"filename": "NotificationFeed+Mapping.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed+Mapping.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 2163,
"line_count": 58
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension NotificationFeed {\n /// Holds numbers of unread notifications for each type of notification.\n struct UnreadNumbers: Decodable, Hashable, Sendable {\n /// The total number of unread notifications\n public let all: Int\n \n /// The number of unread commets.\n public let comments: Int\n \n /// The number of unread mentions.\n public let mentions: Int\n \n /// The number of unread rants from users which the logged in user is subscribed to.\n public let subscriptions: Int\n \n /// The number of unread upvotes.\n public let upvotes: Int\n \n public init(all: Int, comments: Int, mentions: Int, subscriptions: Int, upvotes: Int) {\n self.all = all\n self.comments = comments\n self.mentions = mentions\n self.subscriptions = subscriptions\n self.upvotes = upvotes\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let all: Int\n let comments: Int\n let mentions: Int\n let subs: Int\n let upvotes: Int\n //let total: Int //Not needed because it's the same as `all`.\n }\n}\n\nextension NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers.CodingData {\n var decoded: NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers {\n .init(\n all: all,\n comments: comments,\n mentions: mentions,\n subscriptions: subs,\n upvotes: upvotes\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**Grade: 8**\n\n### Bugs\n- There are no explicit bugs in the given code. However, it is important to ensure data integrity between `CodingData` and `UnreadNumbers`.\n\n### Optimizations\n- The `CodingData` structure could implement a custom initializer that ensures that `all` in `UnreadNumbers` is equal to the sum of other properties if that is a business requirement.\n- Consider renaming the `subs` property in `CodingData` to `subscriptions` to keep consistency across structures.\n\n### Good points\n- The code is well-structured, with appropriately named components.\n- The use of `Decodable`, `Hashable`, and `Sendable` protocols enhances the versatility and functionality of the `UnreadNumbers` struct.\n- Consistent use of access control modifiers (`public`) for properties and initializers where necessary.\n- Efficient transformation from `CodingData` to `UnreadNumbers` using the `decoded` computed property.\n\n### Summary\nThe code snippet provides a well-crafted extension of a `NotificationFeed` class to manage unread notifications efficiently. It is well-structured, establishing clear separation of concerns particularly through the use of Codable structures for decoding and ensuring compatibility with concurrency through the `Sendable` protocol. Minor consistency improvements with property naming and initializing could enhance the code's robustness and readability further.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- [Rocket.Chat](https://github.com/RocketChat/Rocket.Chat) provides notification features that can be extended or used as a reference.\n- [Mattermost](https://github.com/mattermost/mattermost-server) also deals with notifications and could provide additional perspective on handling unread notification counts effectively.",
"filename": "NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 1511,
"line_count": 51
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed.UserInfo.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension NotificationFeed {\n struct UserInfo: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let avatar: User.Avatar\n public let username: String\n public let userId: Int\n \n public init(avatar: User.Avatar, username: String, userId: Int) {\n self.avatar = avatar\n self.username = username\n self.userId = userId\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension NotificationFeed.UserInfo {\n struct UsernameMapEntryCodingData: Decodable {\n let name: String\n let avatar: User.Avatar.CodingData\n }\n}\n",
"review": "8\n\n### Bugs\n- There are no apparent bugs in the provided code snippet.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Ensure that the `User.Avatar` type and `User.Avatar.CodingData` type perform necessary validation or have proper error handling, especially if they are retrieved from or decoded from external sources. This is not visible in the current snippet but is something to watch out for.\n- Consider marking `UsernameMapEntryCodingData` properties as `private` if they do not need to be accessed directly from outside this structure, to enhance encapsulation.\n- Assess if additional convenience initializers or factory methods could be beneficial for `UserInfo`, especially if it needs to be constructed from various other data representations.\n\n### Good points\n- The use of structures ensures value semantics which can help prevent unintended sharing of state.\n- The adoption of `Hashable` allows instances of `UserInfo` to be used in collections that require hashing, like sets or as dictionary keys.\n- The separation of concerns by creating code structures specifically for data coding/decoding is a positive approach.\n\n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured, leveraging Swift's protocols like `Hashable` and `Sendable` to ensure that `UserInfo` instances can participate in hashable collections, and are safe for concurrent usage respectively. The `Decodable` implementation is good practice for handling potential external data input in a structured manner. There is consideration for encapsulation but ensuring the unnecessary exposure of properties remains crucial for maintaining clean architecture.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **Stream**: A popular open-source library for building scalable newsfeeds and activity streams, which might overlap with custom solutions involving user notifications or feeds. Stream allows for robust feed management and personalization.\n- **Rocket.Chat**: Though more comprehensive as a communication solution, it has features around notifications and feed management in its open-source implementation.",
"filename": "NotificationFeed.UserInfo.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed.UserInfo.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 554,
"line_count": 21
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\n/// Contains a list of all notifications for the logged in user and the numbers of unread notifications.\npublic struct NotificationFeed: Hashable, Sendable {\n public enum Category: String, CaseIterable, Sendable {\n case all = \"\"\n case upvotes = \"upvotes\"\n case mentions = \"mentions\"\n case comments = \"comments\"\n case subscriptions = \"subs\"\n }\n \n /// The time when the notifications were last checked.\n public let lastChecked: Date\n \n /// The list of all notifications for the logged in user.\n public let notifications: [Notification]\n \n /// The numbers of unread notifications.\n public let unreadNumbers: UnreadNumbers\n \n /// Infos about the user name and avatar for each user id.\n public let userInfos: [UserInfo]\n \n public init(lastChecked: Date, notifications: [Notification], unreadNumbers: NotificationFeed.UnreadNumbers, userInfos: [UserInfo]) {\n self.lastChecked = lastChecked\n self.notifications = notifications\n self.unreadNumbers = unreadNumbers\n self.userInfos = userInfos\n }\n}\n\nextension NotificationFeed {\n struct CodingData: Decodable {\n struct Container: Decodable {\n let data: NotificationFeed.CodingData\n }\n \n let check_time: Int\n let items: [Notification.CodingData]\n let unread: UnreadNumbers.CodingData\n let username_map: [String: NotificationFeed.UserInfo.UsernameMapEntryCodingData]\n }\n}\n\nextension NotificationFeed.CodingData {\n var decoded: NotificationFeed {\n .init(\n lastChecked: Date(timeIntervalSince1970: TimeInterval(check_time)),\n notifications: items.map(\\.decoded),\n unreadNumbers: unread.decoded,\n userInfos: username_map.map { (key, value) in\n .init(avatar: value.avatar.decoded, username: value.name, userId: Int(key) ?? 0)\n }\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "## 7\n\n### Bugs\n- The `userId` conversion using `Int(key) ?? 0` could default to a potentially unintended `0` if the conversion fails, which might mask underlying data issues.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider adding error handling or logging for `Int(key) ?? 0` conversion to better manage unexpected data.\n- The `Category` enum values such as \"subs\" might benefit from more descriptive naming for clarity.\n- Instead of `TimeInterval(check_time)`, use more descriptive conversion explanations or functions to improve code readability.\n \n### Good points\n- Usage of Swift's `Hashable` and `Sendable` protocols to ensure safety and future-proof the data structures.\n- Organized struct with clear separation between data handling and decoding, enhancing maintainability.\n- Proper utilization of Swift's raw strings in the enum declaration.\n \n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured and demonstrates good practices by leveraging Swift language features like `Hashable` and `Sendable`, ensuring a well-defined type-safe approach for handling user notifications. However, small improvements like error handling for the `userId` conversion and use of descriptive variable names can enhance robustness and readability.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- [SwiftNotificationCenter](https://github.com/nicklockwood/SwiftNotificationCenter): Provides broadcast-style notifications for Swift.\n- [UserNotifications framework by Apple](https://developer.apple.com/documentation/usernotifications): An alternative for handling notifications with official Apple support.",
"filename": "NotificationFeed.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/NotificationFeed.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 1960,
"line_count": 58
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.Content.Elements.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension Profile.Content {\n struct Elements: Hashable, Sendable {\n /// The rants that the user has created.\n public let rants: [Rant]\n \n /// The rants that the user has upvoted.\n public let upvotedRants: [Rant]\n \n /// The comments that the user has created.\n public let comments: [Comment]\n \n /// The rants that the user has marked as favorite.\n public let favorites: [Rant]\n \n /// If the profile is from the logged in user, then this list contains rants that user has viewed in the past.\n public let viewed: [Rant]\n \n public init(rants: [Rant], upvotedRants: [Rant], comments: [Comment], favorites: [Rant], viewed: [Rant]) {\n self.rants = rants\n self.upvotedRants = upvotedRants\n self.comments = comments\n self.favorites = favorites\n self.viewed = viewed\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.Content.Elements {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let rants: [Rant.CodingData]\n let upvoted: [Rant.CodingData]\n let comments: [Comment.CodingData]\n let favorites: [Rant.CodingData]?\n let viewed: [Rant.CodingData]?\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.Content.Elements.CodingData {\n var decoded: Profile.Content.Elements {\n .init(\n rants: rants.map(\\.decoded),\n upvotedRants: upvoted.map(\\.decoded),\n comments: comments.map(\\.decoded),\n favorites: favorites?.map(\\.decoded) ?? [],\n viewed: viewed?.map(\\.decoded) ?? []\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**8**\n\n## Bugs\n- No specific bugs identified in the provided code.\n\n## Optimizations\n- Consider adding documentation or comments for `CodingData` struct to explain its role and parameters for better maintainability.\n- Validate input parameters in the initializer to ensure that no `nil` or unexpected data types are passed (if applicable).\n\n## Good points\n- The code is clean and follows Swift naming conventions.\n- Usage of `Codable` in `CodingData` struct for encoding and decoding operations is efficient.\n- The use of `extension` effectively organizes related functionalities.\n- Handles optional decoding of `favorites` and `viewed` lists gracefully with default values.\n\n## Summary\nThe code defines a Swift struct `Elements` inside the `Profile.Content` namespace. This struct contains properties concerning user interactions on a hypothetical platform, such as `rants`, `upvotedRants`, `comments`, `favorites`, and `viewed` rants. An extension for `Elements` describes a `CodingData` struct conforming to `Codable` for encoding and decoding purposes, and another extension adds a property for decoding instances of `Elements`.\n\nOverall, the code is well-constructed, modular, and easy to understand, maintaining good use of structuring in Swift. It could benefit from additional inline comments or documentation for clarity on less obvious parts like decoding and optional handling. \n\n## Open source alternatives\n- [DevRant API](https://devrant.com/api): An open API for interaction with similar rants and comments features.\n- [Mastodon](https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon): An open-source decentralized platform that might involve similar structuring for rants-like content.\n- [Diaspora*](https://github.com/diaspora/diaspora): While a social network, its content structuring features could be parallel to this approach.",
"filename": "Profile.Content.Elements.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.Content.Elements.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 1600,
"line_count": 49
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.Content.Numbers.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension Profile.Content {\n struct Numbers: Hashable, Sendable {\n /// The number of rants that the user has created.\n public let rants: Int\n \n /// The number of rants that the user has upvoted.\n public let upvotedRants: Int\n \n /// The number of the comments that the user has created.\n public let comments: Int\n \n /// The number of rants that the user has marked as favorite.\n public let favorites: Int\n \n /// The number of collaborations the user has created.\n public let collaborations: Int\n \n public init(rants: Int, upvotedRants: Int, comments: Int, favorites: Int, collaborations: Int) {\n self.rants = rants\n self.upvotedRants = upvotedRants\n self.comments = comments\n self.favorites = favorites\n self.collaborations = collaborations\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.Content.Numbers {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let rants: Int\n let upvoted: Int\n let comments: Int\n let favorites: Int\n let collabs: Int\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.Content.Numbers.CodingData {\n var decoded: Profile.Content.Numbers {\n .init(\n rants: rants,\n upvotedRants: upvoted,\n comments: comments,\n favorites: favorites,\n collaborations: collabs\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**Grade: 7**\n\n### Bugs\n- No apparent bugs identified in the current code.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Ensure consistency by renaming properties in the nested `CodingData` struct to match the public `Numbers` struct for easier understanding and maintainability, or vice versa.\n- Provide validation for the initializer to prevent negative numbers if they are inappropriate for the application context.\n- Consider defining default values or using optionals if there is a scenario where some of the values might not be available, rather than forcing the input of all integers.\n\n### Good points\n- The code correctly conforms to both `Hashable` and `Sendable` protocols, ensuring that the `Numbers` structure can be used in various collections and safely across concurrency boundaries if needed.\n- It provides a clear structure and separation of responsibilities, making it easy to extend or modify without affecting other parts of the code.\n- Good use of `Codable` for easy serialization and deserialization of data.\n\n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured and achieves the intended functionality effectively. It defines a struct `Numbers` with a straightforward purpose of encapsulating user activity metrics, with the addition of a nested `CodingData` struct for encoding/decoding operations. However, property naming inconsistencies could be improved for better clarity, and additional input validations could enhance robustness. The implementation is clean and follows good practices in terms of data encoding and conforming to Swift protocols.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- Swift's built-in `Decodable` and `Encodable` can be effectively used as alternatives to model JSON data without needing separate struct declarations.\n- If using this as part of a larger application, consider frameworks like **SwiftJSON** or **Alamofire** for more comprehensive data handling.",
"filename": "Profile.Content.Numbers.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.Content.Numbers.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 1426,
"line_count": 49
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.Content.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension Profile {\n struct Content: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let elements: Elements\n public let numbers: Numbers\n \n public init(elements: Profile.Content.Elements, numbers: Profile.Content.Numbers) {\n self.elements = elements\n self.numbers = numbers\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.Content {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let content: Elements.CodingData\n let counts: Numbers.CodingData\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.Content.CodingData {\n var decoded: Profile.Content {\n .init(\n elements: content.decoded,\n numbers: counts.decoded\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**Grade: 6**\n\n### Bugs\n- No explicit bugs observed, however, improper usage may occur if the expected behavior or initialization of `Elements` and `Numbers` isn't as anticipated. Any serialization problems can arise if `Elements.CodingData` or `Numbers.CodingData` do not properly conform to `Decodable`.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Ensure that the structures `Elements` and `Numbers`, as well as `Elements.CodingData` and `Numbers.CodingData` implement necessary protocols and error handling.\n- Consider using `@frozen` on the structs if they are not expected to change, which can help the compiler optimize.\n- If thread safety is a concern due to the `Sendable` conformance, ensure that implementations of `Elements` and `Numbers` are deeply immutable.\n\n### Good points\n- Uses `Hashable` and `Sendable` effectively, improving performance in collections and thread safety.\n- The struct's initialization is concise and clear, making the code easy to understand and maintain.\n- Conformity to `Codable` makes it easy to serialize the structs, which is good for data transfer/storage.\n\n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured and uses effective Swift protocols like `Hashable`, `Sendable`, and `Codable`. While there are no explicit bugs visible, cautious use of conformances and applicable methods is essential to prevent runtime issues. Optimization can be achieved by ensuring all underlying types and data conform to the necessary protocols and by verifying thread safety practices. The given data structures are ready for data serialization and thread-safe operations if implemented properly downstream.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- Swift's standard library certainly can cater to basic serialization and data operations, but for extensive JSON handling, `SwiftyJSON` could be used for ease.\n- For more detailed and extensive data encoding/decoding capabilities, `CodableKit` might provide an enriched set of experiences, though regular `Codable` suffices here.",
"filename": "Profile.Content.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.Content.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 6,
"size": 666,
"line_count": 28
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\n/// Holds information, content and the activity history of a user.\npublic struct Profile: Hashable, Sendable {\n /// The user's alias.\n public let username: String\n \n /// The number of upvotes that the user got from other users.\n public let score: Int\n \n /// The time when the user created the account.\n public let created: Date\n \n /// The description of the user.\n public let about: String?\n \n /// The description of the geographic location.\n public let location: String?\n \n /// The description of the user's skills.\n public let skills: String?\n \n /// The user's GitHub reference.\n public let github: String?\n \n /// The user's personal website.\n public let website: String?\n \n /// The user's content and activities.\n public let content: Content\n \n /// The user's large avatar, for profile views.\n public let avatarLarge: User.Avatar\n \n /// The user's small avatar, for rant views and comment views.\n public let avatarSmall: User.Avatar\n \n /// True if the user is subscribed to devRant++.\n public let devRantSupporter: Bool\n \n /// True if the logged in user is subscribed to the user of this profile.\n public var subscribed: Bool\n \n public init(username: String, score: Int, created: Date, about: String?, location: String?, skills: String?, github: String?, website: String?, content: Profile.Content, avatarLarge: User.Avatar, avatarSmall: User.Avatar, devRantSupporter: Bool, subscribed: Bool) {\n self.username = username\n self.score = score\n self.created = created\n self.about = about\n self.location = location\n self.skills = skills\n self.github = github\n self.website = website\n self.content = content\n self.avatarLarge = avatarLarge\n self.avatarSmall = avatarSmall\n self.devRantSupporter = devRantSupporter\n self.subscribed = subscribed\n }\n}\n\npublic extension Profile {\n enum ContentType: String, Sendable {\n /// All user content.\n case all = \"all\"\n \n /// The user's rants.\n case rants = \"rants\"\n \n /// The user's comments.\n case comments = \"comments\"\n \n /// Rants or comments upvoted by the user.\n case upvoted = \"upvoted\"\n \n /// The user's favorite rants.\n case favorite = \"favorites\"\n \n /// The rants viewd by the user.\n case viewed = \"viewed\"\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n struct Container: Codable {\n let profile: Profile.CodingData\n let subscribed: Int?\n }\n \n let username: String\n let score: Int\n let created_time: Int\n let about: String\n let location: String\n let skills: String\n let github: String\n let website: String\n let content: Content.CodingData\n let avatar: User.Avatar.CodingData\n let avatar_sm: User.Avatar.CodingData\n let dpp: Int?\n }\n}\n\nextension Profile.CodingData.Container {\n var decoded: Profile {\n return .init(\n username: profile.username,\n score: profile.score,\n created: Date(timeIntervalSince1970: TimeInterval(profile.created_time)),\n about: profile.about.isEmpty ? nil : profile.about,\n location: profile.location.isEmpty ? nil : profile.location,\n skills: profile.skills.isEmpty ? nil : profile.skills,\n github: profile.github.isEmpty ? nil : profile.github,\n website: profile.website.isEmpty ? nil : profile.website,\n content: profile.content.decoded,\n avatarLarge: profile.avatar.decoded,\n avatarSmall: profile.avatar_sm.decoded,\n devRantSupporter: (profile.dpp ?? 0) != 0,\n subscribed: (subscribed ?? 0) != 0\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "4\n\n## Bugs\n- Misspelled content type `Profile.ContentType.favorite` as \"favorites\" instead of \"favorite\".\n- Misnamed and mismatched JSON keys in `CodingData` struct that don't conform with Swift's naming conventions, such as `created_time`.\n \n## Optimizations\n- Use `CodingKeys` to handle different JSON keys and Swift property names seamlessly.\n- Consider using an enum for properties like `github`, `website`, etc., to handle different types of user references more effectively.\n- `about`, `location`, etc., are strings and could be empty or nil, so consider using a single method or function to handle these checks across the class instead of repeating code.\n- Include error handling or validation for parsing operations to avoid potential runtime errors.\n\n## Good Points\n- Code documentation using comments is clear and thorough, aiding comprehensibility.\n- Usage of `Hashable`, `Sendable`, and `Codable` conformances providing both performance benefits and ease of networking tasks.\n- Logical separation of model into `Profile` and `Profile.CodingData` structures helps keep concerns organized.\n\n## Summary\nThis code encapsulates user profile data effectively with a strong focus on structure and clarity. While the documentation and separation of structures are well executed, the handling of JSON data introduces some potential bugs, especially in naming conventions that can lead to mismatches during encoding/decoding operations. Utilizing Swift's native coding abilities more efficiently and introducing error handling mechanisms would improve the robustness of this implementation.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- **Nodrop**: An open-source project managing simplified user profile data similar to profile management systems.\n- **Parse Swift**: A backend framework that handles data modeling and synchronization between clients and a central server, often used for user profiles and related functionalities.",
"filename": "Profile.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Profile.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 4,
"size": 3938,
"line_count": 124
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Rant.Kind.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension Rant {\n public enum Kind: Int, Sendable {\n case rant = 1\n case collaboration = 2\n case meme = 3\n case question = 4\n case devRant = 5\n case random = 6\n //case undefined = 7 // Not available anymore in the official app\n }\n}\n",
"review": "8\n\n## Bugs\n- No apparent bugs are present in this short snippet of code.\n\n## Optimizations\n- It might be good to include a comment above the cases explaining what `Rant` is for clarity if it isn't clear elsewhere in the code.\n- If there's no plan to support `undefined` in the future, removing or archiving the commented-out code can enhance clarity.\n\n## Good points\n- The use of Swift's `enum` for defining the types is clear and concise.\n- Each case is associated with an integer which makes serialization straightforward if needed.\n- The use of `Sendable` protocol indicates a good understanding of concurrency and safety in Swift.\n\n## Summary\nThis Swift code snippet focusing on defining an enumerated type for `Rant` kinds is clean and well-structured. It adheres to Swift conventions, particularly with respect to using `enum` for a set list of values and implementing the `Sendable` protocol for concurrent execution. Although it appears not to contain any bugs, clarity and forward maintenance would benefit from removing commented-out sections unless they are needed for future reference.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- **GitHub Projects Board**: Similar to enum-like structures in defining issue/feature kinds, GitHub's project boards allow for various categorizations and annotations.\n- **Swift Argument Parser**: A popular library for parsing command-line arguments in Swift, showcasing excellent use of enums for categorizing command types.",
"filename": "Rant.Kind.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Rant.Kind.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 294,
"line_count": 12
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Rant.Weekly.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension Rant {\n /// Holds information about a specific weekly group rant.\n struct Weekly: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let week: Int\n public let topic: String\n public let date: String\n public let uiHeight: Int\n \n public init(week: Int, topic: String, date: String, uiHeight: Int) {\n self.week = week\n self.topic = topic\n self.date = date\n self.uiHeight = uiHeight\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension Rant.Weekly {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let week: Int\n let topic: String\n let date: String\n let height: Int\n }\n}\n\nextension Rant.Weekly.CodingData {\n var decoded: Rant.Weekly {\n .init(\n week: week,\n topic: topic,\n date: date,\n uiHeight: height\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "# 7\n\n## Bugs\n- There are no evident bugs, but the `date` field might lead to issues if the format isn't consistent or validated. Consider using `Date` type or validate the string format.\n\n## Optimizations\n- Consider using `Date` type instead of `String` for the `date` property to leverage date manipulations and formatting.\n- Implement validation logic or conversion when initializing the struct if the data sources are varied for more robust error handling and data integrity.\n- The struct `CodingData` might be more useful if located directly within the `Weekly` struct for better scoping and clarity.\n\n## Good Points\n- The use of separate namespaces (extensions) is a good practice to organize related functionalities.\n- Clean and simple structure which makes the code easy to read and maintain.\n- Conforms to both `Hashable` and `Sendable`, which is good for collections and concurrency.\n\n## Summary\nThe code defines a `Weekly` struct for holding information about weekly group rants, including properties like the week number, topic, date as a string, and a UI height. It also includes a `CodingData` struct that can be serialized and is decoded back into the `Weekly` structure. The code is organized well, using extensions for clarity, though could benefit from enhanced handling of date formatting.\n\n## Open Source Alternatives\n- **DateTimeKit**: A Swift library that provides enhanced date and time functionalities.\n- **JSONCodable**: For more advanced JSON encode/decode functionalities if needed.",
"filename": "Rant.Weekly.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Rant.Weekly.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 849,
"line_count": 37
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Rant.swift.md Normal file
View File

File diff suppressed because one or more lines are too long

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/RantFeed.News.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "public extension RantFeed {\n /// Contains information about news given in rant feeds.\n /// - note: This is mostly used for weekly group rants.\n struct News: Hashable, Identifiable, Sendable {\n public enum Action: String, Sendable {\n case groupRant = \"grouprant\"\n case none = \"none\"\n case rant = \"rant\"\n }\n \n public let id: Int\n \n /// Most of the time this is equal to the value `intlink`, this specifies the type of news.\n /// This should be an enum but it's unknown what the other values are and weekly news are dead anyway.\n public let type: String\n \n /// The headline text of the news.\n public let headlineText: String\n \n /// The contents of the news.\n public let text: String\n \n /// The footer text of the news.\n public let footerText: String\n \n /// The height of the news view on the screen.\n public let height: Int\n \n /// The action that should be performed when the user taps/clicks on the news.\n public let action: Action\n \n public init(id: Int, type: String, headlineText: String, text: String, footerText: String, height: Int, action: Action) {\n self.id = id\n self.type = type\n self.headlineText = headlineText\n self.text = text\n self.footerText = footerText\n self.height = height\n self.action = action\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension RantFeed.News {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let id: Int\n let type: String\n let headline: String\n let body: String?\n let footer: String\n let height: Int\n let action: String\n }\n}\n\nextension RantFeed.News.CodingData {\n var decoded: RantFeed.News {\n .init(\n id: id,\n type: type,\n headlineText: headline,\n text: body ?? \"\",\n footerText: footer,\n height: height,\n action: .init(rawValue: action) ?? .none\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "8\n\n## Bugs\n- None identified based on the provided code.\n\n## Optimizations\n- The `type` property in `News` Struct should ideally be of an enum type for better type safety, even though there are unknown potential values.\n- Consider providing default values for properties in `CodingData` struct for more flexible decoding. \n\n## Good points\n- Utilizes Swift's `Hashable`, `Identifiable`, and `Sendable` protocols, making the `News` struct efficient and ready for use in concurrent contexts.\n- Use of a nested enum `Action` provides clear understanding and type safety for possible actions, reducing errors.\n- Clear separation of data parsing logic into a nested `CodingData` struct to handle encoding and decoding.\n\n## Summary\nThe code is well-structured and adheres to protocol-oriented programming principles common in Swift. There's a clear separation of concerns, especially between the `News` data model and its coding logic. However, further typification of the `type` property could enhance safety and code clarity. The code seems to have been thoughtfully considered and implements Swift's Codable pattern effectively.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- **Swift News API**: Libraries like \"NewsAPI\" which interact with News API for fetching news data can serve as an open-source option for digest functionality.\n- **FeedKit**: Useful for parsing RSS, Atom, and JSON feeds, which might provide similar feed handling functionality.",
"filename": "RantFeed.News.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/RantFeed.News.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 2098,
"line_count": 69
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/RantFeed.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// Contains the list of rants for the logged in user and other random things.\npublic struct RantFeed: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let rants: [Rant]\n \n public let sessionHash: String?\n \n /// The weekly group rant week number.\n public let weeklyRantWeek: Int?\n \n /// True if the logged in user is subscribed to devRant++.\n public let devRantSupporter: Bool\n \n public let numberOfUnreadNotifications: Int\n \n public let news: News?\n \n public init(rants: [Rant], sessionHash: String?, weeklyRantWeek: Int?, devRantSupporter: Bool, numberOfUnreadNotifications: Int, news: RantFeed.News?) {\n self.rants = rants\n self.sessionHash = sessionHash\n self.weeklyRantWeek = weeklyRantWeek\n self.devRantSupporter = devRantSupporter\n self.numberOfUnreadNotifications = numberOfUnreadNotifications\n self.news = news\n }\n}\n\npublic extension RantFeed {\n enum Sort: Sendable {\n /// The devRant algorithm decides what rants appear in the feed.\n case algorithm\n \n /// The most recent rants appear in the feed.\n case recent\n \n /// The top rated rants appear in the feed.\n case top(range: Range)\n }\n \n enum Range: Sendable {\n /// Rants from the one day.\n case day\n \n /// Rants from the one week.\n case week\n \n /// Rants from the one month.\n case month\n \n /// Rants from all time.\n case all\n }\n}\n\nextension RantFeed {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let rants: [Rant.CodingData]\n //let settings //not sure what the purpose is. probably not needed.\n let set: String?\n let wrw: Int?\n let dpp: Int?\n let num_notifs: Int?\n //let unread //probably the same info as already provided by num_notifs, so not needed.\n let news: News.CodingData?\n }\n}\n\nextension RantFeed.CodingData {\n var decoded: RantFeed {\n .init(\n rants: rants.map(\\.decoded),\n sessionHash: `set`,\n weeklyRantWeek: wrw,\n devRantSupporter: (dpp ?? 0) != 0,\n numberOfUnreadNotifications: num_notifs ?? 0,\n news: news?.decoded\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "# Grade: 8\n\n## Bugs\n- No explicit bugs in the code are apparent upon initial review, though there might be logical bugs related to optional handling in `decoded`.\n\n## Optimizations\n- Consider providing default values for optional properties in the initializer to simplify and reduce conditional logic usage.\n- Evaluate if `sessionHash`, `weeklyRantWeek`, and `News` really need to be optional. If they are frequently non-nil, consider using defaults instead.\n\n## Good points\n- Use of well-named and structured types, which improves readability and maintainability.\n- Conforms to `Hashable` and `Sendable`, adhering to recent Swift concurrency and collection patterns.\n- Efficient use of Swift's `enum` to handle different sorting types and time ranges for rants.\n \n## Summary\nThe code is a clean and well-structured implementation of a data structure for a Rant feed in a Swift application, supporting integration with Codable for easy data serialization. It effectively uses enums to categorize sorting options and time ranges for rants and provides a decode method to construct a `RantFeed` from its codable counterpart. While it doesn\u2019t contain explicit bugs, there are opportunities for simplification by avoiding optional properties where possible.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- **RedditKit**: This Swift library can be used to interact with Reddit, which has similarities to a rant-based feed platform.\n- **MastodonKit**: For those who want to interact with Mastodon servers, useful if considering decentralized alternatives akin to microblogging rants.",
"filename": "RantFeed.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/RantFeed.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 2251,
"line_count": 79
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/User.Avatar.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Foundation\n\npublic extension User {\n struct Avatar: Hashable, Sendable {\n public let colorHex: String\n \n public let imageUrlPath: String?\n \n public var imageUrl: URL? {\n imageUrlPath.flatMap { URL(string: \"https://avatars.devrant.com/\\($0)\") }\n }\n \n public init(colorHex: String, imageUrlPath: String?) {\n self.colorHex = colorHex\n self.imageUrlPath = imageUrlPath\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension User.Avatar {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let b: String\n let i: String?\n }\n}\n\nextension User.Avatar.CodingData {\n var decoded: User.Avatar {\n .init(\n colorHex: b,\n imageUrlPath: i\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "**7**\n\n### Bugs\n- No significant bugs identified. The code seems to function as intended in the given context.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider adding validation for `colorHex` to ensure it is a valid hex color.\n- Ensure that `imageUrlPath` is sanitized or validated to prevent malformed URLs.\n- Consider defining a default value for `imageUrlPath` to avoid potential `nil` handling issues.\n\n### Good points\n- Uses Swift's type safety with `URL` construction.\n- Good use of Swift's `Codable` for encoding and decoding of data.\n- Clean use of `extension` to logically extend functionality.\n\n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured, making effective use of Swift's capabilities with structures, extensions, and conditional unwrapping. There's attention to code organization, encapsulating information regarding the user's avatar in a straightforward and reusable manner. Minor improvements can be made in validation and defaults to prevent possible errors.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **GitHub's OctoKit**: A Swift library for interfacing with the GitHub API, which includes features for managing user avatars.\n- **Cocoapods libraries like AlamofireImage**: A library handling image URLs and requests efficiently which can be integrated in place of manual `URL` construction.",
"filename": "User.Avatar.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/User.Avatar.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 7,
"size": 746,
"line_count": 35
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/User.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// Represents a user.\npublic struct User: Identifiable, Hashable, Sendable {\n public let id: Int\n \n public let name: String\n \n /// The number of upvotes from other users.\n public let score: Int\n \n /// True if the logged in user is subscribed to devRant++.\n public let devRantSupporter: Bool\n \n /// A small avatar for the rant views and comment views.\n public let avatarSmall: Avatar\n \n /// A large avatar for the profile view.\n public let avatarLarge: Avatar?\n \n public init(id: Int, name: String, score: Int, devRantSupporter: Bool, avatarSmall: User.Avatar, avatarLarge: User.Avatar?) {\n self.id = id\n self.name = name\n self.score = score\n self.devRantSupporter = devRantSupporter\n self.avatarSmall = avatarSmall\n self.avatarLarge = avatarLarge\n }\n}\n",
"review": "# 9\n\n## Bugs\n- No apparent bugs in the code.\n\n## Optimizations\n- Consider using default values for certain properties in the initializer, if plausible, to simplify object creation.\n- Document the purpose of optional properties like `avatarLarge`, explaining when they might be nil.\n\n## Good points\n- Clear and concise struct definition, fitting good Swift conventions.\n- Appropriate use of `public` access control to expose necessary properties while protecting the struct.\n- Implements `Identifiable`, `Hashable`, and `Sendable` protocols which add versatility to the struct.\n- Provides clear inline documentation for each property, enhancing readability and maintainability.\n\n## Summary\nThe `User` struct is a well-structured and well-documented representation of a user, adhering to Swift conventions and leveraging important protocols (`Identifiable`, `Hashable`, `Sendable`). This struct is highly usable in scenarios where user identity, comparison, or concurrent state sharing is needed. Overall, there are minimal improvements needed, and it represents exemplary use of Swift's struct capabilities.\n\n## Open source alternatives\n- **Realm Cocoa**: Offers object models similar to structs for persistence in iOS applications.\n- **Core Data**: Apple's framework commonly used for persisting app data which can be designed to include user entities similar to this struct.",
"filename": "User.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/User.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 9,
"size": 849,
"line_count": 28
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/VoteState.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// Represents the different kinds of votes that a rant or comment can have.\npublic enum VoteState: Int, Hashable, Sendable {\n /// A given ++ vote.\n case upvoted = 1\n \n /// No votes given.\n case unvoted = 0\n \n /// A given -- vote.\n case downvoted = -1\n \n /// Not able to vote (if the rant or comment belongs to the logged in user).\n case unvotable = -2\n}\n",
"review": "**8**\n\n### Bugs\n- None\n\n### Optimizations\n- None necessary; the code is already concise and efficient.\n\n### Good points\n- Use of `enum` with `Int` raw values simplifies direct comparisons and storage in certain types of collections.\n- Conformance to `Hashable` and `Sendable` is a good practice for future compatibility and concurrency.\n- Clear documentation comments describe each case, enhancing the understandability.\n- The use of negative, zero, and positive values is intuitive for this domain context (voting logic).\n\n### Summary\nThe code is well-structured, efficiently using Swift's `enum` to categorize vote states with associated integer values. The choice to adopt `Hashable` and `Sendable` suits modern Swift programming best practices, aiding in serialization and safe concurrency. There are no apparent bugs or necessary optimizations, and the documentation is clear and concise.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **Swift's `Result` Type**: Although more generic, it can be used for similar representations in voting systems.\n- **Custom Implementations in Projects like Mastodon or Lemmy**: Often, custom voting systems can be seen in open-source frameworks of social media platforms, providing rich functionalities.",
"filename": "VoteState.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/VoteState.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 388,
"line_count": 15
}

11
.reviews/Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Weekly.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "/// The weekly item data for the list of weeklies.\npublic struct Weekly: Hashable, Identifiable, Sendable {\n /// The number of the week. The first week starts with 1.\n public let week: Int\n \n /// The weekly subject/topic.\n public let topic: String\n \n /// The US formatted date the weekly.\n public let formattedDate: String\n \n /// How many rants have beeon posted for this weekly.\n public let numberOfRants: Int\n \n public var id: Int { week }\n \n public init(week: Int, topic: String, formattedDate: String, numberOfRants: Int) {\n self.week = week\n self.topic = topic\n self.formattedDate = formattedDate\n self.numberOfRants = numberOfRants\n }\n}\n\nextension Weekly {\n struct CodingData: Codable {\n let week: Int\n let prompt: String\n let date: String\n let num_rants: Int\n \n struct List: Codable {\n let weeks: [CodingData]\n }\n }\n}\n\nextension Weekly.CodingData {\n var decoded: Weekly {\n .init(\n week: week,\n topic: prompt,\n formattedDate: date,\n numberOfRants: num_rants\n )\n }\n}\n",
"review": "8\n\n### Bugs\n- Typographical error in the comment: \"beeon\" should be \"been\".\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider using a date object (e.g., `Date`) instead of a string for `formattedDate` to make date manipulations easier and less error-prone.\n- Documentation comments might benefit from additional details or a consistent format for future maintainability.\n- Consider adding unit tests to validate the correctness and robustness of the code.\n\n### Good points\n- The code uses structures and extensions effectively to maintain clean separation of concerns.\n- Adopting Swift protocols like `Hashable`, `Identifiable`, and `Sendable` helps in integrating with SwiftUI and concurrency features.\n- Proper use of Swift's `Codable` for easy encoding and decoding of data structures.\n\n### Summary\nThis piece of code is generally well-written and leverages Swift's powerful type system and protocols effectively. It has a strong separation between data representation and encoding/decoding rules, making it easier to manage and adapt. A minor issue with a typographical error in the documentation is present, but otherwise, the code is clean and efficient.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- **Swift Weekly Brief**: This newsletter provides weekly updates and insights into the Swift community; projects associated might have similar models.\n- **CodableKit**: An open source library that simplifies encoding and decoding in Swift, potentially extending the functionalities demonstrated here.",
"filename": "Weekly.swift",
"path": "Sources/SwiftDevRant/Models/Weekly.swift",
"directory": "Models",
"grade": 8,
"size": 1178,
"line_count": 48
}

11
.reviews/Tests/SwiftDevRantTests/SwiftDevRantTests.swift.md Normal file
View File

@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
{
"extension": ".swift",
"source": "import Testing\n@testable import SwiftDevRant\n\n@Test func example() async throws {\n // Write your test here and use APIs like `#expect(...)` to check expected conditions.\n}\n",
"review": "8\n\n### Bugs\n- No apparent bugs in the provided code.\n\n### Optimizations\n- Consider adding a more meaningful test name instead of `example` for clarity and better maintainability.\n- Add a comment or improve the documentation for the purpose and expected outcome of the test case.\n\n### Good points\n- The use of `@testable` import allows for testing of internal components, which is effective for unit testing in Swift.\n- Use of async/await pattern, which is modern and appropriate for dealing with asynchronous code.\n\n### Summary\nThe provided code snippet is a simple and clean setup for an asynchronous unit test in Swift using the `@testable` import. While it doesn't contain much detail, it employs modern Swift testing practices. Improvements can be made in naming conventions and documentation for enhanced clarity.\n\n### Open source alternatives\n- Quick (https://github.com/Quick/Quick): A behavior-driven development framework for Swift.\n- Nimble (https://github.com/Quick/Nimble): A matcher framework for Swift used in conjunction with Quick for a BDD approach.",
"filename": "SwiftDevRantTests.swift",
"path": "Tests/SwiftDevRantTests/SwiftDevRantTests.swift",
"directory": "SwiftDevRantTests",
"grade": 8,
"size": 175,
"line_count": 7
}