tikker/review.md

markdown
# Keylogger Program Analysis

## Overview

This document reviews a C-based program designed to monitor multiple keyboard devices for input events and log them into a database. The code includes mappings of keycodes to character representations and utilizes system calls to interact with input devices efficiently.

## Code Highlights

### Bugs
- **Key Mapping:** The `keycode_to_char` array lacks comprehensive keycode definitions, leading to potential null pointer dereferences.
- **Security Risk:** SQL injection vulnerability due to direct variable embedding in queries.
- **Unhandled Returns:** Undefined behavior for unknown keycodes, potentially causing `NULL` insertions in the database.

### Optimizations
- Implement error handling for `snprintf` in loops and use `strncasecmp` for safer keyboard checks.
- Minimize `EVIOCGNAME` calls by caching device names.
- Bound checks to prevent `keycode_to_char` array access overflow and batch `read` operations for performance.
- Ensure proper resource cleanup, including database connection closure.
- Adopt dynamic memory allocation if `device_path` exceeds 32 characters.

### Strengths
- Efficient monitoring of multiple devices using `fd_set` and `select()`.
- Proper use of `snprintf` to prevent buffer overflow.
- Logical division between device acquisition and event processing.

## Summary

Despite its functional capability, the program presents issues primarily in security, efficiency, and resource management. Addressing vulnerabilities and performance limitations could substantially enhance its reliability.

### Recommendations

Consider using open-source alternatives for better functionality:
- **Logkeys:** Offers broader functionality and community support.
- **Keylogger:** Lightweight with active development on GitHub.