9 ### Bugs - No significant bugs found in the visible portion of the code. ### Optimizations - Simplify the Codable conformance by making `AttachedImage` conform directly to `Codable` instead of using a nested struct for encoding/decoding. - Consider using `URL` type instead of `String` for the `url` property for better type safety and validation. ### Good points - Adheres to Swift's best practices with the use of `public` access control. - Smart use of `Hashable` and `Sendable` protocols suggesting immutability and safety in concurrent programming contexts. - Clear and straightforward initialization method. ### Summary The `AttachedImage` struct is well-designed with a focus on thread safety and immutability, as indicated by its conformance to `Sendable` and `Hashable`. The code is clean and concise, with only minor suggestions for improvement mainly around potential simplification and improved type safety. ### Open source alternatives - **Kingfisher**: A powerful, pure-Swift library for downloading and caching images from the web. - **SDWebImage**: An asynchronous image downloader with cache support as a UIImageView category.